Should your New Year’s resolutions include cleaning out your inbox?

Reva Minkoff admits she has a hoarding problem — an email hoarding problem, that is.The head of a Chicago-based digital marketing agency, Minkoff says her personal inbox is “constantly proliferating” to the point that she now has 686,000 emails sitting in it. “It’s like a full-time job to be on top of it. It’s very hard to unclutter,” she says.
Minkoff is hardly alone. With a daily flurry of messages from friends and colleagues, plus an ever-flowing stream of solicitations, newsletters and more, many of us are contending with email overload. Minkoff says the situation becomes all the more vexing during the holiday season because of the multitude of offers from businesses. They’re “emailing up to five times per day,” she says. All of which begs the big question: Should we start the new year with a clean slate and delete all our old emails? Certainly, a case can be made for the fact a cluttered inbox hinders productivity. One survey from 2020 found that more than 60% of millennials had anxiety over email overload. A similar percentage said it hampered workplace activity. Those who make the effort to do the big purge often say they are happier for it. “It’s cleaned my soul to see (my inbox) so fresh and empty,” said one respondent to a recent Reddit thread that asked the question, “What do you have too much of?” (Many on the thread pointed to their emails.)The average inbox size? 8,024 emails Still, it doesn’t take long for that empty inbox to fill up, however. A PandoDaily study from a few years ago, based on data collected from 38,000 inboxes, found that the average inbox has 8,024 emails. But that same study found that about 20% of users have inboxes with more than 21,000 emails, though it also noted that most large inboxes “top out under 100,000 emails.” Philadelphia-based publicist Gia Vecchio has 75,000 emails in her inbox. But Vecchio says she prefers things that way because she likes to access older messages in case there are details that may be relevant. It’s one thing to have the email contacts, she says, but it’s another to have the actual emails, which provide information that could prove valuable later on — say, about the quality of service from a vendor she hired in the past. “I need the context,” says Vecchio of her justification for refusing to delete messages.

Gia Vecchio says she has no issues with her inbox of 75,000 emails, but some business experts warn that too many emails might spell trouble.

Courtesy Gia Vecchio

Some business experts warn that too many emails might spell trouble, however. A crowded inbox could be a sign you’re not staying on top of your work life, says Carrie Greene, a business coach based in New Jersey. “The things in your inbox are decisions you haven’t made,” she says. Plus, it’s the kind of clutter we simply don’t need: “If you think about it, if it was actual mail, would you keep 300,000 pieces?” she says. Greene advises clients to put emails into one of three categories — the kind you deal with immediately, the kind you delete and the kind you delay in handling, but only for a short while. Ultimately, the goal is to have an empty or nearly empty inbox, she says. “From my point of view, I don’t think even having 100 emails in your inbox is good,” Greene concludes. Minkoff, the head of the Chicago digital-marketing agency, is trying to embrace such a philosophy, though she concedes it’s a challenge. “I used to spend an hour a night just trying to clean out things,” she says.Would you pay $100 to manage your inbox? Of course, email providers also suggest ways you can stay on top of your inbox. Google
which is behind the Gmail service, offers a variety of tips and strategies and notes that users can create filters that automatically delete or forward certain messages. Other companies have also stepped into this arena. Last year, Basecamp, a software firm, started its mail service, which it bills as a “fresh approach (that) transforms email into something you want to use, not something you’re forced to deal with.” Specifically,, which runs $100 a year for personal use, offers automatic features that range from blocking emails from certain senders to organizing newsletters into a dedicated space. Basecamp co-founder Jason Fried says the service can’t do anything about the emails you’ve already accumulated, however. But at this point. he says that’s a losing battle for many people. “They need to declare bankruptcy and start with a fresh inbox,” he says.‘Precious moments in a curio cabinet’ Betsy Smith, who owns a Pennsylvania-based social-media marketing firm, says she has no need to make such declarations. Even while her husband maintains what she dubs an “inbox zero” philosophy, she is content with her 82,000 emails, spread across two inboxes, saying “you never know when you might need” to look at something. In other words, she’s a proud email hoarder. “I keep them all like precious moments in a curio cabinet. Having them sit there gathering virtual dust makes me happy,” she says.

You may also like...